Netflix reportedly attempted to secure exclusive film and television adaptation rights to Microsoft’s massive library of Xbox gaming franchises in a deal worth $500 million. However, Xbox leadership apparently believed its intellectual properties were worth considerably more, countering with an astonishing $800 million demand that ultimately went nowhere.
According to Matthew Belloni of Puck News, Netflix’s former chief content officer Bela Bajaria proposed a seven-year exclusive licensing agreement covering Xbox properties. Belloni cited three sources familiar with the negotiations, revealing that Xbox CEO Asha Sharma and Microsoft’s business affairs team responded by asking for an additional $300 million.
The negotiations have since collapsed, with Netflix withdrawing its original offer entirely.
While neither company has publicly confirmed the reported financial figures, Microsoft’s response suggests that the gaming giant remains determined to expand its franchises into Hollywood, but not for cheap.
Netflix Wanted Seven Years of Exclusive Xbox Adaptations
The proposed arrangement would have given Netflix exclusive licensing rights to develop film and television adaptations of Xbox titles for seven years.
Considering Microsoft’s enormous collection of gaming properties, the implications of such an agreement would have been significant.
Microsoft controls franchises including Halo, Gears of War, The Elder Scrolls, Fallout, Doom, Diablo, Warcraft, and Call of Duty, among numerous others acquired through its purchases of Bethesda parent company ZeniMax Media and Activision Blizzard.
However, Belloni’s report does not specify exactly which franchises would have been included in the proposed Netflix agreement, nor does it establish whether existing licensing arrangements would have been affected.
Nevertheless, even a portion of Microsoft’s gaming library could potentially provide years of television programming and feature films.
According to Belloni, Bajaria offered $500 million for the seven-year arrangement, but Sharma and her team countered with $800 million.
Netflix chief financial officer Spencer Neumann was reportedly among those who considered Microsoft’s asking price excessive.
The Logo for Netflix – Netflix
READ: Former BioWare Employees Leak Mass Effect 5 Trailer
The situation became even more complicated when Bajaria departed Netflix during the company’s recent executive shakeup.
With the executive responsible for initiating the negotiations no longer at the company, Netflix reportedly withdrew its offer.
Rather than continuing negotiations over one enormous exclusive agreement, Microsoft is now said to be pursuing smaller licensing arrangements with multiple Hollywood partners.
Xbox Responds to the Report
Although Netflix declined to comment on Belloni’s reporting, Microsoft issued a statement emphasizing Hollywood’s growing interest in its gaming properties.
“We have received record-breaking interest in our I.P.; Netflix is a valued partner and we are excited for the forthcoming release of our Minecraft and Diablo animated series together, among other adaptations,” Xbox told Puck.
Asha Sharma at Microsoft Build 2024 – Microsoft Events, YouTube
The statement is particularly noteworthy because it confirms that Microsoft and Netflix intend to continue collaborating despite the apparent collapse of their much larger licensing negotiations.
Netflix already has a live-action Gears of War adaptation in development, while Microsoft’s statement points to additional animated projects involving Minecraft and Diablo.
The companies clearly have an existing business relationship, but Microsoft apparently has little interest in surrendering broad exclusivity over its properties without substantial compensation.
Did Microsoft Overvalue Its Gaming Franchises?
The obvious question is whether Microsoft made the correct decision by demanding $800 million rather than accepting Netflix’s original offer.
On one hand, $500 million is an enormous amount of money, particularly for licensing rights that would last only seven years.
On the other hand, Microsoft’s gaming library contains some of the most recognizable franchises in entertainment.
Amazon’s Fallout television series demonstrated that a video game adaptation can become a major streaming success, while Warner Bros.’ A Minecraft Movie proved that gaming properties can also generate substantial theatrical revenue.
Microsoft would understandably want to avoid undervaluing franchises with that kind of potential.
A scene from Halo Season 2 (2024), Paramount+
READ: You Can Request Money From Ebenezer Scrooge This Christmas
However, there’s another consideration that should concern gamers: What would Netflix have actually done with those properties?
Hollywood’s history of adapting video games has been decidedly inconsistent.
Paramount’s live-action Halo series remains a particularly relevant example. The adaptation faced considerable criticism from longtime fans over its treatment of Master Chief, its departures from established lore, and creative decisions that frequently seemed disconnected from the source material.
The series was canceled after two seasons.
Netflix has experienced its own share of adaptation controversies, including its widely criticized live-action Resident Evil series, which was canceled after a single season.
At the same time, Netflix has demonstrated that it can produce successful gaming adaptations. Arcane, based on Riot Games’ League of Legends, and Cyberpunk: Edgerunners, based on CD Projekt Red’s Cyberpunk universe, received considerable praise.
An image from Gears of War: E-Day – XBOX Games Studio, The Coalition, People Can Fly
The difference frequently comes down to whether the people adapting these properties understand what made the original games successful.
Handing one streaming company exclusive access to a substantial collection of beloved gaming franchises would not necessarily guarantee that those properties received the creative attention they deserved.
Microsoft’s New Hollywood Strategy Could Be Better for Gamers
Microsoft’s reported decision to pursue smaller agreements with multiple partners could ultimately prove more beneficial than signing one massive exclusivity contract.
Rather than placing numerous franchises under Netflix’s umbrella, Microsoft could theoretically select individual studios, filmmakers, and streaming platforms based on their suitability for particular properties.
A Doom adaptation does not necessarily require the same creative approach as The Elder Scrolls. Likewise, a Gears of War movie presents entirely different challenges from an animated Diablo series.
Allowing those properties to find different creative homes could provide Microsoft with greater flexibility, although the actual degree of creative control would depend on the terms of each agreement.
Of course, there’s no guarantee that Microsoft’s leadership will make the right decisions.
The Xbox Series X Console – YouTube, Xbox
The company has already demonstrated through Halo that owning a beloved gaming franchise does not automatically translate into understanding how to adapt it successfully.
And with Microsoft’s gaming business undergoing significant changes, including the recent turmoil surrounding the broader industry, the company may be increasingly interested in finding additional revenue opportunities outside traditional video game sales.
Still, the reported negotiations reveal something important about how Microsoft views its entertainment properties. Netflix apparently believed seven years of Xbox adaptations were worth $500 million. Microsoft believed they were worth at least $800 million. Whether that valuation proves justified is open to interpretation. But for gamers, the more important question isn’t whether Microsoft can extract hundreds of millions of dollars from Hollywood.
It’s whether the resulting movies and television shows will actually respect the franchises that made those properties valuable in the first place.
Do you think Xbox should have signed with Netflix? Sound off and let us know!
UP NEXT: ‘Obsession’ Star Inde Navarrette Says Gen Z Is Sick of Corporate Slop and Wants Original Movies
