Biopics have had a busy year in 2026, from the box office success of Michael to the awards buzz surrounding I Play Rocky. The trend shows little sign of slowing, and one of its latest entries brings two Oscar winners to Prime Video. So far, critics have given it a cold reception.
David O. Russell’s Madden stars Nicolas Cage as legendary football coach and broadcaster John Madden. At the time of writing, the film held a 15% critic score on Rotten Tomatoes based on 40 reviews. Its audience score stood at 53% from more than 250 ratings.

Nicolas Cage as John Madden – Prime Video, YouTube
The film follows Madden from his Super Bowl win with the Oakland Raiders to his career in broadcasting and the development of the video game series that bears his name. Christian Bale co-stars as Raiders owner Al Davis.
Critics Say Madden Strains to Entertain
Decider’s John Serba wrote that Madden “plays like an overamped game of dress-up.” He took particular issue with Russell’s all-caps “STYLE,” which he called “irritating, loud, hyperactive and overly self-conscious.” Robert Daniels at RogerEbert.com went further, calling the film “the nadir of Russell’s career.”
William Bibbiani of TheWrap thought the film’s affection for its subject got in the way of the storytelling. “Madden is so desperate to be loved that, unlike Madden himself, it can’t be respected,” he wrote. The Associated Press’ Jake Coyle found that the cast rarely clicked as a comic ensemble. “No one can get on the same page, and the pages aren’t much good, anyway.”

Nicolas Cage as John Madden – Prime Video, YouTube
READ: Anne Hathaway Welcomes Baby No. 3 With Adam Shulman
David Rooney of The Hollywood Reporter acknowledged that he’s no football fan. He suspected the film’s rapid editing and steady supply of period songs were there to keep viewers engaged through a story he thought would mostly appeal to people with “an insatiable appetite for American football history.” His review raises a fair question for a biopic about a figure this familiar. How much interest does the movie generate on its own, and how much does it expect viewers to bring with them?
Variety Finds Something to Like in the Chaos
Variety’s Owen Gleiberman gave Madden one of its few Fresh reviews. He saw the gamble in putting Cage under heavy prosthetics and letting him lean into his own eccentricities to play a man whose personality was already larger than life. The approach struck him as only partly convincing, but he found something to enjoy in the sheer energy of it.

Nicolas Cage as John Madden – Prime Video, YouTube
READ: HBO Renews The Gilded Age for Season 5 After Only Three Season 4 Episodes
“Madden is a stunt biopic on cinematic amphetamines,” Gleiberman wrote. At times, he said, it played like a straight-faced Saturday Night Live sketch, albeit one “shot and edited by Scorsese.” The review helps explain why the movie might work for some viewers. If the prospect of watching Cage go big as Madden is what gets potential viewers to press play, the excess is part of the appeal.
Early Audiences Are Divided, Too
A low Tomatometer score can be a poor predictor of how fans will respond to a movie.As That Park Place reported when Michael opened, the Michael Jackson biopic had a 40% critic score and a 96% verified audience score. The Super Mario Galaxy Movie pulled in $122.1 million worldwide in its first two days after a wave of negative reviews.
With more than 250 audience ratings on Rotten Tomatoes, Madden has won over just over half of the viewers who weighed in. Early individual scores on Criticless range from 50% to 83%, with too few ratings to call a consensus. That leaves room for football fans to warm to the film as more people find it on Prime Video. So far, though, even the viewers giving Madden a fairer hearing than critics are having trouble agreeing on whether it’s worth watching.
Have you seen Madden? If so, what did you think? Sound off and let us know!
UP NEXT: GTA VI Shatters Internet Traffic Records as Mixed Player Reception Clouds Historic Launch

