Disney is moving forward with another attempt to revive the beloved Home Alone franchise, this time recruiting Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg to develop a Christmas sequel featuring original star Macaulay Culkin.
However, the announcement comes as director Chris Columbus questions whether the Christmas classic can ever be successfully recreated without a vital part of its original cast.
According to Variety, Rogen and Goldberg are developing the screenplay alongside Culkin and will produce the project through their Point Grey production company.
The film is in early development at Disney’s 20th Century Studios, with no release date or additional casting announcements.
While Culkin’s return offers a potentially compelling reason to revisit the franchise, Columbus believes the absence of Catherine O’Hara, who portrayed Kevin McCallister’s mother in the original films, presents a significant obstacle.
Chris Columbus Questions Another Home Alone Sequel
In an interview with Variety, Columbus explained that the success of Home Alone depended on far more than its elaborate traps and physical comedy.
“Catherine, as I’ve always said, is 50% of Home Alone,” Columbus stated.
The director emphasized that O’Hara and Culkin provided the emotional foundation of the original film, transforming what could have been a straightforward comedy into a memorable story about family.

Catherine O’Hara in Home Alone – Disney Plus, YouTube
O’Hara passed away in January at the age of 71, making a reunion of the original mother-and-son pairing impossible.
Columbus also criticized the franchise’s later installments, arguing that subsequent filmmakers failed to understand the importance of the original cast.
He specifically praised Joe Pesci and Daniel Stern, whose performances as Harry and Marv helped establish the distinctive comedic identity of the first two movies.
Interestingly, Columbus reportedly made his comments shortly before learning that Disney was developing another sequel. When contacted afterward, he declined further comment.
Macaulay Culkin Could Return as an Adult Kevin McCallister
The proposed sequel would mark Culkin’s first feature-film appearance as Kevin McCallister since 1992’s Home Alone 2: Lost in New York.
According to TheWrap, Culkin has been involved in discussions about returning to the franchise, with the actor reportedly pitching a new approach to the familiar story.
Culkin previously described a concept involving an adult Kevin who has become a father himself.
In that proposed storyline, Kevin struggles to maintain a relationship with his son because of his demanding career. The child eventually locks Kevin outside their home and constructs elaborate traps to prevent him from returning.

Macaulay Culkin – McDonald’s, YouTube
The premise would reverse the original film’s formula, placing Kevin in the position previously occupied by the Wet Bandits.
The house would also serve as a metaphor for Kevin’s strained relationship with his child.
Although the concept could provide a natural continuation of Kevin’s story, Disney has not confirmed whether the finished film will follow that exact premise.
Can Disney Recapture the Original’s Christmas Magic?
The challenge facing Disney isn’t simply convincing audiences to watch another Home Alone movie. It’s demonstrating that the franchise still has a worthwhile story to tell.
The original succeeded because its outrageous physical comedy was balanced by a sincere emotional narrative about a child discovering the importance of his family.
Columbus’ concerns highlight how easily that balance could be lost when a studio attempts to revive a recognizable property decades after its original success.

Harry and Marve in Home Alone 2 – Disney+
Culkin’s participation is certainly an encouraging development, particularly if the sequel explores Kevin’s relationship with his own family rather than simply repeating the original formula.
Nevertheless, Disney’s previous attempts demonstrate that recognizable branding and familiar slapstick comedy are not necessarily enough.
With Rogen and Goldberg developing the screenplay and Columbus openly questioning the viability of another installment without O’Hara, the studio faces the difficult task of proving that Home Alone has something meaningful left to offer audiences.
For now, whether another trip to the McCallister household can recapture the original’s enduring Christmas appeal remains an open question.
Do you want to see Seth Rogen in charge of Home Alone? Sound off and let us know!
UP NEXT: GTA VI Audience Reviews Tank on Metacritic — Gaming Media Blames ‘Review Bombing’


