The first social media reactions for Amazon MGM’s upcoming Masters of the Universe adaptation have kicked off an intense debate online after one reviewer praised the film for exploring themes of “fragile masculinity.”
The reaction came from Andrew J. Salazar, co-owner and managing editor of Discussing Film, who posted his early thoughts on X after seeing the movie.
MASTERS OF THE UNIVERSE is like a sister film to the first Thor. Struggles to find its footing in the first half, but once it locks on its themes of fragile masculinity and ego, it makes way for an incredibly fun time that’s also visually stimulating. Nicholas Galitzine is great! pic.twitter.com/w0sprjgNZw
— Andrew J. Salazar (@AndrewJ626) May 19, 2026
READ: James Cameron Says ‘Avatar’ 4, 5, Can’t Happen Without Massive Retooling
Salazar wrote: “Masters of The Universe is like a sister film to the first Thor. Struggles to find its footing in the first half, but once it locks on its themes of fragile masculinity and ego, it makes way for an incredibly fun time that’s also visually stimulating. Nicholas Galitzine is great!”
That phrasing immediately became a lightning rod among longtime fans of He-Man, many of whom have grown increasingly frustrated with Hollywood’s tendency to reinterpret classic franchises through modern political or social frameworks.
Audiences have become increasingly wary whenever reviewers begin throwing around phrases like “fragile masculinity,” “toxic masculinity,” or other politically charged terminology in connection with beloved properties.
Why Fans Were Already Concerned About The Movie
For many viewers, this controversy didn’t begin with Salazar’s review.
Director Travis Knight had already raised eyebrows in previous interviews when he described Skeletor as representing “the embodiment of toxic masculinity.” Actress Camila Mendes, who plays Teela, also discussed how her version of the character was shaped by “toxic masculinity” and the pressures of surviving in Eternia’s world.
Those comments led to fears that Masters of the Universe might follow the same path as several recent legacy franchise reboots which critics embraced for political messaging and general audiences pushed back on.
As a result, many fans were already approaching the movie cautiously long before the first reactions dropped online.
So when Salazar specifically highlighted themes of “fragile masculinity” in his Masters of The Universe review, it reinforced concerns that the film might prioritize commentary over escapist fantasy storytelling.
Others Insist The Movie Is Being Misrepresented
However, there’s another side to the debate that has emerged almost immediately. Several online personalities and fans claim the movie itself is not nearly as politically focused as some critics are suggesting.
Nate from the Mr. H Reviews YouTube channel has repeatedly referenced a source who allegedly attended screenings of the film and told him that none of the “toxic masculinity” discourse feels overt within the actual movie.
READ: Damon Lindelof Says His Rey Movie Would Have Explored the Divide Between Old and New Star Wars Fans
According to those claims, Masters of the Universe is largely a straightforward fantasy action film and not some heavy-handed ideological lecture.
One of the most widely shared responses came from Lord Brian Urso, who directly challenged Salazar’s interpretation of the movie.
He wrote: “JUST because you WANT to put in far left buzzwords like ‘toxic masculinity’ in a film, and LOOK for things like that doesent mean it was ACTUALLY IN THERE. The people i know that actually saw it , said it was awesome space fantasy fun, and have NO IDEA what the hell you are talking about.”
A tweet by Lord Brian Urso about a Masters of The Universe review – X, @TheMobRules73
The response resonated with many fans who believe entertainment critics increasingly analyze movies through ideological lenses that general audiences neither notice nor care about.
The Debate Around “Modern Audiences” Continues
The larger issue surrounding Masters of the Universe reflects a broader divide that has been growing in entertainment culture for years.
Fans of older franchises increasingly worry that Hollywood no longer adapts beloved properties for the existing audience that made them successful in the first place. Instead, many believe studios are attempting to reshape those properties around contemporary cultural conversations.
Meanwhile, defenders of those creative decisions argue that modern storytelling naturally evolves alongside changing social attitudes and expectations.
That tension has now landed squarely on Masters of the Universe.
Jared Leto as Skeletor in the Masters of the Universe trailer – YouTube @AmazonMGMStudios
At the moment, it remains unclear whether the film itself actually pushes these themes in a meaningful way or whether reviewers are simply emphasizing elements that average viewers may barely notice while watching the movie.
Either way, the controversy has already placed the film under a microscope before general audiences have even had a chance to see it for themselves.
And in today’s entertainment landscape, perception can sometimes become just as important as the movie itself.
Do you think Masters of The Universe will be about themes of “fragile masculinity”? Sound off in the comments and let us know!
