Headline  ·  News  ·  Video Games

GTA VI Earns Near-Perfect Review Score, Challenges Ocarina of Time’s Historic Metacritic Record

Lucia leaning out the passenger window of a red car as Jason drives through Vice City in Grand Theft Auto VI

Credit: Rockstar Games

Rockstar Games may have just delivered one of the most critically acclaimed video games in history if the review score of GTA VI is to be believed.

The first reviews for Grand Theft Auto VI have arrived, and the long-awaited blockbuster has debuted with an astonishing 99 out of 100 on Metacritic, matching the legendary score of Nintendo’s original The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time.

The achievement comes nearly 28 years after Ocarina of Time launched on the Nintendo 64 in 1998, establishing a critical benchmark that has remained virtually untouchable.

According to Dexerto, Grand Theft Auto VI currently occupies the top position in Metacritic’s all-time rankings, immediately ahead of Nintendo’s classic. However, both games share the same rounded score of 99, making them tied numerically.

With Grand Theft Auto VI scheduled to launch on November 19 for PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S, the early critical reception suggests that Rockstar’s latest installment may actually live up to its extraordinary expectations.

Critics Shower Grand Theft Auto VI With Perfect Scores

The review embargo lifted on November 18, unleashing an overwhelmingly positive response from gaming publications around the world.

According to MP1st’s review roundup, numerous major outlets awarded the game perfect scores, including IGN, GameSpot, Game Informer, PlayStation Universe, Eurogamer, GamesRadar+, and Giant Bomb.

Other publications were similarly enthusiastic. Noisy Pixel awarded the game a 9/10, while Wccftech delivered a 9.6/10.

A man and a woman in a video game holding guns in a Miami-like city

GTA 6 promotional art showing Lucia and Jason – Rockstar

Writing for Forbes, Paul Tassi reported that 80 of the first 109 reviews gave the game a perfect score.

The remarkable reception extends beyond Metacritic. Early reports also place Grand Theft Auto VI at 98 out of 100 on OpenCritic, another major review aggregation website.

For a game carrying more than a decade of anticipation, that level of critical agreement is an extraordinary achievement.

However, the critical consensus doesn’t necessarily mean every player will share the same enthusiasm once the game becomes widely available.

Grand Theft Auto VI Matches One of Nintendo’s Greatest Achievements

The comparison with The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time is particularly significant.

Released in November 1998, Nintendo’s groundbreaking adventure transformed the gaming industry through its innovative three-dimensional world, lock-on combat system, cinematic storytelling, and elaborate dungeon design.

Its influence can still be felt throughout modern action-adventure games, and its 99 Metacritic score has long served as a benchmark for critical excellence.

Now, Rockstar has matched that achievement with a game representing an entirely different approach to interactive entertainment.

Link and Epona in The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time

Link and Epona in The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time – Nintendo

Where Ocarina of Time helped establish the foundations of modern three-dimensional adventures, Grand Theft Auto VI appears to push the boundaries of open-world design, environmental detail, and player freedom.

The comparison is especially interesting following the recent release of Nintendo’s Ocarina of Time remake for Switch 2, which has introduced the beloved adventure to another generation of players.

Of course, matching a review score doesn’t automatically establish that one game is superior to another. Different generations of critics evaluate games against different technological expectations and industry standards.

Nevertheless, the fact that Rockstar’s latest blockbuster is being discussed alongside Nintendo’s 1998 masterpiece speaks volumes about its initial reception.

Rockstar Sets a New Standard for Its Own Franchise

Even without the Nintendo comparison, Grand Theft Auto VI has already achieved something remarkable within Rockstar’s catalog.

The company’s previous highest-rated title was Grand Theft Auto IV, which earned a Metacritic score of 98.

Both Grand Theft Auto V and Red Dead Redemption 2 received scores of 97, placing them among the most acclaimed releases of their respective generations.

A man and a woman in a video game riding a jetski

GTA 6 promotional art – Rockstar

With its initial 99 Metascore, Grand Theft Auto VI has surpassed all three.

The latest installment returns players to Vice City and the fictional state of Leonida, following protagonists Jason Duval and Lucia Caminos through an expansive criminal adventure.

Rockstar has promised a massive open world filled with activities, detailed environments, and an evolving narrative. Early reviews suggest the developer has delivered on many of those ambitions.

The critical response also arrives as the game prepares for what could become one of the largest commercial launches in entertainment history.

Grand Theft Auto VI’s Metacritic Score Could Still Fall

Despite the historic opening, there’s an important qualification.

The game’s 99 Metacritic score is not guaranteed to remain unchanged.

Metacritic calculates its scores using a weighted average of published reviews. As additional critics submit their evaluations, the overall score can increase or decrease. A larger number of reviews awarding the game scores below 10/10 could eventually push its average down to 98 or even lower.

That means Grand Theft Auto VI‘s current position above Ocarina of Time in the rankings could prove temporary.

GTA 6 Couple

Lucia and Jason, the playable couple in GTA 6 – YouTube, Rockstar Games

Nintendo’s original adventure has maintained its extraordinary 99 Metascore for decades, while Rockstar’s latest release is still experiencing its initial review cycle.

There’s also the question of how ordinary consumers will respond once millions of players begin exploring Leonida for themselves.

Professional reviews provide an early indication of a game’s quality, but long-term audience reception, technical performance, and player satisfaction will ultimately contribute to its legacy.

For now, however, Rockstar Games has accomplished something that few developers have managed in nearly three decades.

Grand Theft Auto VI has arrived to near-universal critical acclaim, matched one of gaming’s most celebrated records, and positioned itself as an early contender for one of the greatest video games ever released.

Whether it ultimately deserves that distinction will be decided over the years ahead, not simply by its opening Metacritic score.

How do you feel about this GTA VI early review score? Sound off and let us know!

UP NEXT: Variety Promotes Hunter Schafer as Robert Pattinson’s First Bond Girl

Marvin Montanaro is the Editor-in-Chief of That Park Place and a seasoned entertainment journalist with nearly two decades of experience across multiple digital media outlets and print publications. He joined That Park Place in 2024, bringing with him a passion for theme parks, pop culture, and film commentary. Based in Orlando, Florida, Marvin regularly visits Walt Disney World and Universal Orlando, offering firsthand reporting and analysis from the parks. He’s also the creative force behind The M4 Empire YouTube channel, bringing a critical eye toward the world of pop culture. Montanaro’s insights are rooted in years of real-world reporting and editorial leadership. He can be reached via email at [email protected] SOCIAL MEDIA: X: http://x.com/marvinmontanaro Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/marvinmontanaro Facebook: https://facebook.com/marvinmontanaro YouTube: http://YouTube.com/TheM4Empire Email: [email protected]