HBO has released the first full clip from its upcoming Harry Potter television series, offering fans an extended look at Hogwarts’ Great Hall and the new actors bringing J.K. Rowling’s characters to life.
The footage is already generating mixed reactions online, with viewers criticizing its muted colors, lack of warmth, and less prominent magical details compared to director Christopher Columbus’ original 2001 film.
Meanwhile, a new exchange between Albus Dumbledore and Minerva McGonagall suggests HBO’s adaptation will explore events beyond Harry Potter’s perspective.
The approximately 90-second clip, titled “The Start-of-Term Banquet,” arrives ahead of the series’ December 25 premiere.
A First Look at the Hogwarts Welcome Feast
The scene takes place shortly after Harry Potter’s arrival at Hogwarts and the Sorting Ceremony.
Students enthusiastically chant Dumbledore’s name as the headmaster, played by John Lithgow, prepares to begin the traditional welcome feast.
Harry, portrayed by Dominic McLaughlin, turns to Ron Weasley (Alastair Stout) and asks whether Dumbledore is “a bit mad.”
“Yep, totally off his rocker,” Ron responds.

Alastair Stout as Ron Weasley – HBO, YouTube
READ: Taco Bell Customer Says She Was Owed $9.39 in Change but Got No Coins at All
Dumbledore then snaps his fingers, magically summoning an assortment of food onto the tables. The dishes appear from below, with some bouncing and tumbling as the platters arrive.
The sequence also offers a taste of Hans Zimmer’s new musical approach to the Wizarding World, replacing the familiar sound established by John Williams in the original films.
Although the scene recreates a recognizable moment from Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone, its visual presentation has become a particular source of criticism.
Fans Criticize Muted Colors and Missing Warmth
Compared to Columbus’ original film, which presented Hogwarts’ Great Hall with warm golden lighting and rich colors, HBO’s version has a noticeably cooler and more subdued appearance.
Some viewers on X have circulated edited versions of the footage, increasing the contrast and color saturation to demonstrate how the scene might look with lighting closer to the original movie.
What happened to color correction? It’s so flat and gray. This took me 5 minutes and it’s just a little contrast and saturation https://t.co/gHXRc4eHaQ
— 1/4 Black Garrett (@QTRBlackGarrett) November 15, 2026
One viewer complained, “I’ve been supporting this show but I got to be honest… It just looks bad Kinda like a parody. Colour is off, doesn’t feel magical, and what is that chanting Dumbledoor That’s not in the book, it’s just cringe”

The Hogwarts banquet hall – HBO, YouTube
Another wrote, “The color is so diluted. The first Harry Potter movie’s dinner scene was bright and colorful and this looks like someone tried to copy it without understanding what made the movies fantastic.”
@OneTakeNews The color is so diluted. The first Harry Potter movie’s dinner scene was bright and colorful and this looks like someone tried to copy it without understanding what made the movies fantastic. https://t.co/B1w1BrzTXq
— AltArtist (@RealAltartist) November 15, 2026
The floating candles have also attracted criticism.
In Rowling’s novel and Columbus’ adaptation, hundreds of candles suspended above the students help establish the Great Hall as a place of wonder. Although candles are visible in HBO’s version, they are positioned much higher and are considerably less prominent.
“The no candles hurts. Looks like a Walmart food ad,” one user wrote on X.
@davidellison The no candles hurts. Looks like a Walmart food ad
— Brett (@BrettDonn) November 15, 2026
The criticism highlights a challenge facing HBO’s adaptation. The original films established an instantly recognizable visual identity for Hogwarts, and the new production is being measured against those familiar images.
A New Scene Moves Beyond Harry’s Perspective
While much of the online discussion has focused on the show’s appearance, the clip also reveals a potentially more consequential departure from the original books: HBO’s willingness to tell parts of the story outside Harry Potter’s perspective.
Toward the end of the footage, Dumbledore and Professor McGonagall, played by Janet McTeer, share a private conversation about Harry’s placement in Gryffindor.
McGonagall remarks on the boy’s striking resemblance to his father, James Potter.

Dumbledore and Professor McGonagall – HBO, YouTube
READ: Universal Orlando Opens Sales for the 2027 Military Freedom Pass, Starting at $230
“Looks can be deceiving, Minerva,” Dumbledore replies. “His nature is entirely his own.”
The exchange does not appear in Rowling’s original novel or Columbus’ film. More significantly, it takes place entirely outside Harry’s perspective.
The Harry Potter novels are written primarily from Harry’s point of view, with readers generally discovering information alongside the young wizard. Private conversations between adults are therefore largely absent unless Harry happens to overhear them.
By including this exchange, HBO signals a willingness to expand the narrative beyond its central character, potentially giving supporting characters additional development and exploring events that Harry never witnesses.
Such an approach could take advantage of the television format’s longer running time, although it also raises questions about how closely the adaptation will follow the novels’ narrative structure.
Can HBO Recapture the Magic?
HBO’s Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone premieres December 25, 2026, with an eight-episode first season.
The extended format offers opportunities to explore characters and storylines that received less attention in the films. HBO’s willingness to move beyond Harry’s perspective suggests the series may also take a different approach to telling Rowling’s story.
However, the early criticism demonstrates that expanding the narrative is only part of the challenge. HBO must also convince viewers that its interpretation of Hogwarts can capture the magic that made the original films so memorable.
What do you think of HBO’s first Harry Potter clip? Sound off and let us know!
UP NEXT: Xbox 25th Anniversary Console Sells for $5,000 at GameStop

