It’s a bird, it’s a plane… it’s another tired attempt to politicize a beloved American hero as Superman has been decalred a “gay icon” by Out Magazine.
In a recent article, Out Magazine has officially declared Superman a “gay icon,” claiming the Man of Steel has always been a symbol of the PRIDE community. According to their reasoning, Superman’s costume, secret identity, outsider status, and physique all make him some sort of coded metaphor for being gay.
Someone better tell Lois…
Rahcel Brosnahan as Lois Lane in Superman – YouTube, DC
Let’s set the record straight: Superman was never designed as a gay allegory. He was created in 1938 by two Jewish immigrants, Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster, as a fantasy of hope during the Great Depression. A hero who stood for truth, justice, and — yes — the American way. He’s a man who chooses to do good not because of who he is, but because of what he believes. He’s a symbol of timeless morality and personal responsibility — not modern identity politics.
Oh, and he’s in love with a woman and has canonically been in love with her for almost 90 years.
The ‘Secret Identity’ Argument Falls Flat
The article claims Superman’s dual life as Clark Kent and Superman is a metaphor for being in the closet. But secret identities are literally a staple of every superhero — from Batman to Spider-Man. That doesn’t make them all gay. It makes them human, flawed, and narratively compelling.
Clark Kent in Hames Gunn’s Superman – YouTube, DC
Suggesting that any character with a hidden life is secretly a symbol for a particular identity is lazy analysis at best and disingenuous rewriting at worst.
Outsider ≠ Allegory
Yes, Superman is an outsider. He’s an alien. He comes from another planet. That’s the whole point — he’s not one of us, and yet he chooses to be one of us and protect us anyway. Framing that as some kind of identity metaphor ignores the real subtext. He’s sent here as a baby, assimilates into our culture, and chooses to uphold values he wasn’t born into.
That’s why he represents the American ideal. He wasn’t born here, but he loves and embodies everything good about it.
Dean Cain as Superman – YouTube, Dean Cain Gallery
This isn’t about exclusion — it’s about aspiration. Superman is what we strive to be, not a cipher for every subculture’s feelings of being misunderstood.
Let’s Talk About That Costume…
Tights and a cape? That’s called superhero attire. Always has been. Superman wasn’t created to appear at a PRIDE parade — he was created to leap tall buildings in a single bound and punch evil in the face.
Tyler Hoechlin as Superman in Superman & Lois (2023), The CW
Reducing his costume to a identity-driven fashion statement is not only juvenile — it’s insulting to what the suit represents: courage, honor, and legacy.
Hypermasculinity Is Not Sexuality
The article bizarrely argues that Superman’s masculine physique is part of his appeal to gay men — as if being in shape now automatically implies such subtext. Superman has a perfect physique because he’s, well, Superman. Just like Hercules, Captain America, or any action hero worth his salt.
Henry Cavill as Superman in Man of Steel – HBO Max
Being aspirational doesn’t mean being coded. Not everything has to be reinterpreted through a identity-focused lens.
The Ongoing Pattern of Rewriting Canon for Clout
Out declaring Superman a “gay icon” isn’t a one-off. It’s part of a much larger trend of rebranding canonically straight or non-sexual characters as gay — often with zero basis in the source material — purely to generate headlines, win internet points, or insert identity politics where they were never intended.
Superman is just the latest target. Here are just some of the others.
Captain America
Activists spent years insisting Steve Rogers and Bucky Barnes were secretly in love in the MCU, even launching the viral campaign #GiveCaptainAmericaABoyfriend.
Chris Evans as Captain America in Captain America: Civil War (2016), Marvel Studios
This, despite the fact that Cap’s entire arc centers around his love for Peggy Carter — which Marvel never deviated from.
Elsa (Frozen)
After Let It Go became an anthem of self-expression, activist media pushed the idea that Elsa must be gay because she didn’t have a male love interest.
Disney declined to “give her a girlfriend,” but that didn’t stop countless articles from branding her a PRIDE icon anyway.
M3GAN
A robotic murder doll somehow became a “gay icon” just because she dances in the trailer and roasts people before killing them. Outlets like Them and The Advocate ran glowing pieces praising her “fabulous energy,” as if campiness alone equals representation.
A screenshot from the trailer for M3GAN – YouTube, Universal Pictures
Ahead of the recent sequel, M3GAN embraced her role as a “gay icon” and even called it her “default setting. The film then proceeded to flop epically at the box office.
The Babadook
A horror movie demon was mistakenly categorized as gay on Netflix… and the internet turned it into a full-blown identity movement. The press followed, seriously calling The Babadook a “symbol of living with suppressed identity.”
Pennywise the Clown
After memes paired the child-eating clown from It with rainbow edits and drag quotes, he too was crowned a gay icon — because irony has apparently replaced storytelling.
This isn’t about representation. It’s about appropriation — taking established characters and warping them to fit a modern ideological mold, regardless of canon, authorial intent, or audience reception.
What’s Really Going On Here?
This isn’t about Superman. This is about cultural capture — the ongoing effort by activist media to retroactively rebrand universally loved characters into mascots for modern ideology. The strategy is always the same: take a hero with broad appeal, project a new narrative onto them, and then declare anyone who objects as backward or bigoted as you attempt to wall off the established fanbase.
David Corenswet as Superman flying in James Gunn’s “Superman” – YouTube, DC
But people aren’t buying it. You don’t need to turn Superman into a “gay icon” to justify his relevance. He already matters. He’s already powerful. And he already includes everyone — because he stands for values that transcend identity.
Truth. Justice. The American Way.
That’s what makes Superman iconic.
Superman and Lois Lane kiss while flying in the trailer for James Gunn’s Superman – YouTube, DC
And no amount of revisionist headlines is going to change that.
How do you feel about Superman being declared a “gay icon” by Out Magazine? Sound off in the comments and let us know!
UP NEXT: Warner Bros Tried and Failed to Poach Kevin Feige from Disney Marvel to Run DC
