Headline  ·  News  ·  Video Games

Asmongold Fires Back at Geoff Keighley Over 007 Game of The Year Nomination

Asmongold via AsmongoldTV on YouTUbe

Asmongold took aim at 007 First Light’s Game of the Year nomination after Geoff Keighley unveiled the 2026 shortlist. The streamer questioned how IO Interactive’s James Bond game made the cut ahead of five titles he thought were more deserving, including Capcom’s Pragmata.

“007 First Light? Over Crimson Desert, Onimusha, Palworld, Pragmata, and Fire Emblem?” Asmongold wrote in his reply to Keighley on X. “007 was the most obvious industry plant that, despite dozens of ‘showcases’ and universal media praise, had a mediocre release and 0 cultural relevance,”

James Bond points a gun in an image from 007 First Light

James Bond in the 007 First Light video game trailer – IO Interactive, YouTube

READ: First Look Inside Sea Notes, the Little Mermaid Piano Lounge Coming to the Disney Believe

007 First Light is one of six Game of the Year finalists, alongside Control Resonant, Grand Theft Auto VI, Phantom Blade Zero, Resident Evil Requiem, and The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. The sales figures give Bond a stronger defense than Asmongold allows. His argument gets more interesting when it turns to what players took away from the games the jury passed over.

Bond Had a Strong Launch

IO Interactive and Amazon MGM Studios announced that 007 First Light sold 1.5 million copies in its first 24 hours, making it the fastest-selling game in IO Interactive’s history. By August, the companies said it had sold 4 million copies in its first three months. That’s a strong commercial showing for what Asmongold called a “mediocre release.”

The game also gives jurors a reason to put it on the shortlist. As GameSpot noted in its review, IO Interactive brought some of its Hitman stealth design to Bond. In an early hotel mission, players can eavesdrop, distract guards, or bluff their way into restricted areas. Letting Bond talk his way past a guard makes his charm part of the gameplay.

Asmongold’s jab about “cultural relevance” is harder to settle with sales figures or reviews. What did players find worth talking about after they finished the game? Several of the titles he named are worth a closer look, and Pragmata may offer the clearest example of how a game can stay with players long after they put down the controller.

Why Pragmata Stuck With Players

Capcom’s Pragmata had to introduce players to an original world and an unfamiliar cast. It sold more than 2 million copies in 16 days, and its central relationship gave players something more personal to talk about than a sales milestone.

A video game scene with a young girl giving a high five

Hugh and Diana in Pragmata – Capcom

READ: The Ocarina of Time Remake Is Already Running on PC, and Lawyers Say Nintendo Won’t Have an Easy Fight

As That Park Place previously reported, the bond between security officer Hugh Williams and Diana, a childlike android, prompted some players to reflect on their own families. One player shared that Diana reminded him of his late daughter and that playing the game helped him grieve. It’s one player’s experience, but it gives some substance to a debate that can otherwise get stuck on sales charts and review scores.

The relationship also shapes how Pragmata plays. Diana hacks enemy systems in real time while Hugh handles the shooting. Players have to solve puzzles under fire, so the partnership that drives the story also drives the combat. Both Pragmata and 007 First Light earned Best Action / Adventure nominations.

Who Gets to Decide Game of the Year?

Asmongold’s “industry plant” jab points to a question about how The Game Awards chooses its nominees. Keighley announced the shortlist. Under the awards’ rules, he has no vote. An international jury of more than 100 media and influencer outlets picks the nominees in most categories. Fans get a say once the shortlist is set. Their votes count for 10 percent of the final tally, and the jury’s votes account for 90 percent.

Geoff Keighley from The Game Awards

A screenshot of Geoff Keighley from The Game Awards – YouTube, TheGameAwards

READ: Disney and Visa Deal Brings Hong Kong Disneyland Perks and Makes Visa the Presenting Sponsor of D23 Asia

Asmongold saw the showcase appearances and glowing reviews as signs of how much the industry had embraced 007 First Light. When he brought up games like Crimson Desert, Palworld, and Pragmata, he was asking the shortlist to reflect the games players were still talking about.

The Game Awards describes Game of the Year as “Recognizing a game that delivers the absolute best experience across all creative and technical fields.” That’s where Pragmata makes an especially strong case. The relationship players responded to is also what makes its combat work. Every fight asks players to rely on Hugh and Diana working together.

Would you have put Pragmata ahead of 007 First Light for Game of the Year? Sound off and let us know!

UP NEXT: McDonalds Launches Home Alone Themed Adult Happy Meal This Christmas

Trevor Denning’s work has appeared in The Banner, Upstream Reviews, and The Daily Caller, while his fiction is included in several anthologies from independent presses. A graduate of Cornerstone University in Grand Rapids, Mich., he currently resides in the palm of Michigan’s mitten. Most days you’ll find him at home, working out in his basement gym, cooking, and doting on his cats. You can follow him on X, Criticless, and YouTube at @BookstoreThor