Captain America: Brave New World has taken a steep fall in its second weekend, with a massive 71.8% decline at the domestic box office. The Anthony Mackie-led superhero film pulled in just $28.2 million from Friday through Sunday, according to Box Office Mojo, a sharp contrast to its $100 million five-day double holiday opening weekend. This significant drop is raising serious concerns about the film’s staying power and the Marvel Cinematic Universe’s continued struggles at the box office.
The 71.8% decline is particularly alarming when considering that the film made more on its opening day (February 14) than it did over the entire second weekend, making this weekend’s result a clear reflection of waning audience interest and poor word-of-mouth. In fact, the film’s Friday-to-Friday drop was a staggering 82.4%, indicating a significant rejection by moviegoers after the initial holiday rush.
Anthony Mackie behind the scenes of Marvel Studios’ CAPTAIN AMERICA: BRAVE NEW WORLD. Photo by Eli Adé. © 2024 MARVEL
READ: Captain America Brave New World’s Second Weekend Drop Puts Future of Marvel in Serious Question
While Brave New World maintained its first-place spot at the box office, it was more a result of a lack of strong competition than a testament to the film’s strength. The film has now grossed $141 million domestically and $289.4 million worldwide to date. While these numbers may seem solid at first glance, they are far from reassuring when factoring in the film’s enormous budget.
One of the most contentious points surrounding Brave New World has been the film’s true cost. While many media outlets continue to cite the official $180 million production budget, insiders and industry experts have reported that the actual figure is significantly higher. Multiple rounds of costly reshoots are believed to have ballooned the total production costs to somewhere between $350 million and $375 million.
This means the film would need to gross close to $900 million globally just to break even after factoring in marketing, distribution fees, and theater cuts. With its current worldwide total sitting at just under $290 million, Brave New World is falling well short of that target.
Harrison Ford as the Red Hulk in Captain America: Brave New World – YouTube, Marvel Entertainment
What’s also raising eyebrows is how certain media outlets have been spinning the box office numbers to present the film in a more favorable light. Variety, for instance, has reported a 68% second-weekend drop. However, this figure is based on a comparison between the Friday-to-Sunday period of the film’s opening weekend, which grossed $88.8 million, rather than the $100 million five-day double holiday total that was widely publicized, which is a fair comparison to make. However, Variety never mentions the $88.8 million figure, opting instead to tout a massive six figure domestic opening weekend for the Disney film.
By selectively using the smaller figure for comparison and not clarifying, the reported percentage drop appears less severe, even though the actual decline from the full five-day total paints a much bleaker picture.
Such framing has led many to question the narratives being pushed by mainstream entertainment outlets, particularly given the significant gap between audience reception and media coverage.
Captain America/Sam Wilson (Anthony Mackie) in Marvel Studios’ CAPTAIN AMERICA: BRAVE NEW WORLD, exclusively on Disney+. Photo courtesy of Marvel Studios. © 2024 MARVEL
Massive second-weekend drops are not unheard of for comic book films, but the 71.8% fall places Brave New World in troubling company. Its decline is on par with other recent Marvel disappointments like Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania, which saw a 70% drop following a $106 million debut, and Eternals, which also suffered a sharp fall in its second weekend.
By contrast, films like Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3 saw a more modest 47% decline after a $118 million opening, allowing it to endure at the box office and ultimately become one of the few recent MCU films to cross the $800 million mark globally.
Even Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness and Thor: Love and Thunder, both of which experienced steep second-weekend declines of 67%, managed to post stronger initial openings, giving them more breathing room to reach profitability.
(L-R): Natalie Portman as Mighty Thor and Chris Hemsworth as Thor in Marvel Studios’ THOR: LOVE AND THUNDER. Photo by Jasin Boland. ©Marvel Studios 2022. All Rights Reserved.
It’s clear that Brave New World’s steep drop is not just the result of standard box office trends but is being fueled by poor reception and lackluster word-of-mouth. The film earned a B- CinemaScore, the lowest in MCU history, signaling that audiences left the theater underwhelmed. This tepid response has translated directly into the second-weekend decline, as fewer moviegoers are encouraging others to see the film.
Negative reviews have also played a role. Critics have widely panned the film for its muddled plot, inconsistent tone, and overreliance on reshoots, which many believe led to a disjointed final product. Director Julius Onah has attempted to downplay the significance of the reshoots, stating, “We did one period of additional photography, which is the same on all of these movies. There are so many variables, and [additional photography] becomes essential to fine-tuning and coming up with a thing that we know audiences will love.”
However, insiders have painted a different picture, describing a chaotic production marred by shifting creative decisions, costly reshoots, and the late addition of Giancarlo Esposito’s villainous character Sidewinder.
With its second weekend drop now confirmed, the future of Captain America: Brave New World looks increasingly bleak. The film would need exceptionally strong holds in the coming weeks, as well as a robust international performance, to even approach profitability. Given current trends and audience sentiment, that seems unlikely.
Anthony Mackie as Sam Wilson/Captain America in Marvel Studios’ CAPTAIN AMERICA: BRAVE NEW WORLD. Photo courtesy of Marvel Studios. © 2024 MARVEL
The MCU has seen its share of highs and lows over the past few years, but the steep decline of Brave New World—combined with its massive budget—makes this one of the most concerning releases for Marvel Studios to date. If this trend continues, it will raise serious questions about the direction of the franchise and the audience’s growing fatigue with superhero films.
For now, Captain America: Brave New World stands as yet another cautionary tale in the MCU’s post-Endgame era—where brand recognition alone is no longer enough to guarantee box office success.
How do you feel about the Captain America: Brave New World second weekend dropoff? Sound off in the comments below and let us know!
UP NEXT: Hammer Films Announces its First New Monster Movie in 60 Years
And the customers’ overall interest in Marvel/Disney… just dropped another 70%.
Do you think the people who went to see Brave New World were disappointed that they didn’t get any Soma?
I don’t know. But they definitely got Huckster instead of Huxley.
I said on W. D. W. Pro’s article about the drop that shill media tries to paint the opening weekend as a success only for the veneer to fall away a week later. I should have also mentioned they don’t stop trying even then.
By its nature, shill media lives and dies by the success or failure of the movies they shill for or against. If they can’t convince the public a flop is a success, or a “right-wing” film is a failure when it’s a massive hit, they aren’t fulfilling their purpose for existing and studios will eventually just pull their funding from them.
This movie was “inspired” by BLM. They made Captain America into Captain BLM. The they realised Trump would win the election, and had to reshoot it, to stop looking utterly ridiculous. Disney are woke, and, like all wokists, they are absolute fools.
The media is woke, too. Paid by globalists to churn out propaganda.
Even this website is a bit sloppy in that respect, at times. Virtue-signalling, and that.