YouTube film pundit Grace Randolph is facing intense backlash online after invoking the late Chadwick Boseman while discussing circumstances surrounding filmmaker Matt Reeves, leading to accusations of recklessness and inappropriate behavior.
Damn Grace, sometimes saying less is better. Is she aware what she is doing? pic.twitter.com/DBo1LppHTP
— When Batmen Fly (@whenbatmenfly) April 9, 2025
In a recent video, Grace Randolph stated: “If you knew what Matt Reeves was dealing with you’d just leave him alone as I’m going to do. I mean it’s not a Chadwick Boseman situation, but it’s close. And I hope it doesn’t turn into that. You should leave Matt Reeves alone.”
The cryptic nature of her statement, combined with the direct comparison to Boseman—who privately battled colon cancer before his passing in 2020—immediately drew criticism from fans and creators alike.
Grace Randolph via Beyond The Trailer YouTube
Beau DeMayo, the former showrunner of X-Men ’97, did not hold back in his condemnation. He posted: “This is abhorrent behavior, and the delight in her voice as she reports it is just gross. This is why so many creators who do what you can’t so openly dislike you.”
DeMayo followed up with a more pointed accusation.
Disgusting. Does she have any idea what she could trigger him to do??
Knowingly reporting on someone’s personal mental health struggles, knowing it will only exacerbate and put that person at serious risk, is criminal and the epitome of “those who can’t do, gab.” Linking it to… https://t.co/ttf88k4GKF
— Beau DeMayo (@BeauDemayo) April 10, 2025
“Disgusting,” he said.” Does she have any idea what she could trigger him to do? Knowingly reporting on someone’s personal mental health struggles, knowing it will only exacerbate and put that person at serious risk, is criminal and the epitome of ‘those who can’t do, gab.’ Linking it to Chadwick Boseman is perfectly Karen in the park behavior. If this was a woman, she’d be crying sexism. It works both ways. Find another way to make a living @gracerandolph and have some respect. Creators aren’t characters in your podcasting fanfic for likes. Hope you got your dopamine kick off his struggle.”
Beau DeMayo via Cool YouTube Guy YouTube
DeMayo’s remarks introduced a new layer to the controversy, as he specifically framed the issue as involving mental health. While Grace Randolph did not specify the nature of what Matt Reeves may be experiencing, DeMayo referred to it as “personal mental health struggles” and warned that public speculation could “trigger” Reeves, further intensifying concern. Whether DeMayo was speaking from personal knowledge or making an assumption, his comments shifted the tone of the backlash, with many now criticizing Randolph for potentially exposing a deeply private emotional battle.
@GraceRandolph this is beyond inappropriate of you. Do better. Matt Reeves has a freaking family that may not know. If you’re telling the truth then you exposing this is the lowest thing you have done and I didn’t know you could go lower than you have before. SMH. Do better. We… https://t.co/ShTMHFXDcg
— The Daily Kryptonian (@TheDailyKrypto) April 10, 2025
X account The Daily Kryptonian echoed the sentiment, writing: “@GraceRandolph this is beyond inappropriate of you. Do better. Matt Reeves has a freaking family that may not know. If you’re telling the truth then you exposing this is the lowest thing you have done and I didn’t know you could go lower than you have before. SMH. Do better. We love you Matt.”
Day in and day out grace randolph gives us more reason to despise her and somehow manages to outdo herself every time. @GraceRandolph please do the entire community a favor and find a new career. https://t.co/AU0noYVubq
— The Bat in the Hat (@batgoat15) April 10, 2025
READ: China Hollywood Ban Would Be Symbolic—Not Significant—Thanks to Shrinking Box Office Returns
Another user, *The Bat in the Hat*, added: “Day in and day out Grace Randolph gives us more reason to despise her and somehow manages to outdo herself every time. @GraceRandolph please do the entire community a favor and find a new career.”
The Batman Confronts The Penguin in The Batman – YouTube, Warner Bros. Pictures
As of publication, Matt Reeves has not commented on the Grace Randolph situation, and no public details regarding any health-related issues have been confirmed.
This incident has reignited debate over boundaries in fan commentary and the ethical responsibilities of online pundits when discussing private matters involving public figures. Grace Randolph has not responded to the backlash as of this writing.
Do you believe Grace Randolph acted inappropriately by floating this rumor about Matt Reeves? Sound off in the comments and let us know!
UP NEXT: House of the Dragon Showrunner Responds to George R.R. Martin’s Concerns About the Show
