Featured  ·  Opinion  ·  Rumors  ·  TV

RUMOR: Peter Capaldi to Appear in Harry Potter Series After Snape Casting Backlash

January 8, 2025  ·
  Raven Redgrave
Peter Capaldi

Peter Capaldi speaking at the 2017 San Diego Comic Con International, for "Doctor Who", at the San Diego Convention Center in San Diego, California. Photo Credit: Gage Skidmore from Peoria, AZ, United States of America, CC BY-SA 2.0 , via Wikimedia Commons

Peter Capaldi might appear in the Harry Potter franchise. According to rumor, the former Doctor Who is being considered for a role in the upcoming HBO reboot.

Though only a rumor at this time, confirmation of Peter Capaldi in the Harry Potter series could turn fan sentiments around following a string of controversial rumors and announcements.

Peter Capaldi

Peter Capaldi as the 12th Doctor, YouTube, Doctor Who

READ: Zuckerburg Kicks Bias to the Curb as Meta Embraces User-Driven Fact-Checking with Community Notes

The Harry Potter series has continuously made the news over potential casting choices, and not all of it has been well-received. The first instance occurred years ago when the adult version of Hermione Granger was race-swapped to be a black woman in the Broadway play Harry Potter and The Cursed Child.

A more recent example was the announcement that Paapa Essiedu, a black man, was being considered for the role of Severus Snape, filling the shoes of the late-great Alan Rickman.

These casting choices were met with intense backlash from fans, who wanted to see more accurate representations of their favorite characters and avoid politically motivated race swaps. For more on the Snape backlash, check out the video linked above from Gothic Therapy.

Other announcements have revealed that Albus Dumbledore may also have been cast, with either Mark Rylance or Gary Oldman taking up the mantle of Hogwarts Headmaster. 

Peter Capaldi is most known for his portrayal of the 12th incarnation of the iconic Doctor in Doctor Who. Now, he might get to play another iconic role in another iconic British staple.

Harry Potter

Daniel Radcliffe as Harry Potter in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets (2002), Warner Bros. Pictures

READ: Universal Studios Hollywood Forced to Shut Down as Pacific Palisades Fires Ravage Southern California

A Reddit user citing insider sources revealed that Peter Capaldi is being considered for a role in the new show, with many surmising that it could be Garrick Ollivander, the wand maker of Diagon Alley. In the movies, Mr. Ollivander was played by the late John Hurt, who also played The War Doctor in Doctor Who’s 50th anniversary special.

Peter Capaldi certainly looks the part. Plus, it could be seen as something of an homage to John Hurt to have two Doctors portray the same role. 

Harry Potter Casting Call

An image for the UK Open Casting Call for HBO’s Harry Potter series

If true, this casting alone might bring viewers in droves. Capaldi is an incredible actor and his fans want to see him succeed. But a rumor is still a rumor. Until HBO makes an official announcement, we can’t be sure of anything. We encourage you, for now, to take this with a grain of salt (it’s Reddit, after all!)

What do you guys think? Do you want to see Peter Capaldi in Harry Potter? Have you already written the HBO Harry Potter Show off after the Snape casting rumors? Let us know in the comments below!

Raven Redgrave, AKA Writing Raven, is the co-host of the Gothic Therapy YouTube channel with her husband MasterOfTheTDS. The channel features a look at pop culture, entertainment, and gaming with insightful commentary, sharp critiques, and a dose of dark humor.

UP NEXT: Hulk Hogan Booed by Los Angeles WWE RAW Crowd After Supporting Donald Trump, But Was That The Reason Why?

Author: Raven Redgrave
Raven Redgrave (also known as The Writing Raven) is the cohost of the Gothic Therapy YouTube channel. She is the Gothic half of the channel, while her husband, MasteroftheTDS, is the Therapy. They cover pop-culture with a twist. SOCIAL MEDIA: X: http://x.com/WritingRaven2 YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@GothicTherapy