Anthony Mackie, the actor currently portraying Captain America in Captain America: Brave New World, has stirred up controversy with recent comments that many view as dismissive of the character’s foundational connection to the United States.
In a press event held at the Hotel De La Ville in Rome, Italy, Mackie claimed to the European audience, “Captain America represents a lot of different things and I don’t think the term ‘America’ should be one of those representations. It’s about a man who keeps his word, who has honor, dignity, and integrity.”
Anthony Mackie of Captain America brave new world doesn’t think America is one of the things captain America represents… Boy, did you not get the memo? America just voted for trump, your film is dead on arrival. Stop the pandering shit. pic.twitter.com/0gGFS95S6d
— Nate, or, Mr H Reviews (@MrHreviews) January 28, 2025
READ: Elon Musk Heavily Rumored to Boldly Go Into Paramount Takeover to ‘Make Star Trek Great Again’
This statement comes at a particularly inopportune time just a week after the inauguration of President Donald Trump. With a new U.S. president just sworn in—one who ran on the patriotic “America First” platform—it seems tone-deaf for the actor playing a literal symbol of the United States to suggest that Captain America shouldn’t embody the ideals of America.
Mackie’s comments have left many wondering: Is he saying America is no longer a place where men keep their word? Does he believe the country lacks honor, dignity, and integrity?
Captain America/Sam Wilson (Anthony Mackie) in Marvel Studios’ CAPTAIN AMERICA: BRAVE NEW WORLD, exclusively on Disney+. Photo courtesy of Marvel Studios. © 2024 MARVEL.
The backlash has been swift, with critics accusing Mackie of pandering to a European audience by undermining the very essence of Captain America while promoting the film overseas. Mackie went on to describe the character as “someone who is trustworthy and dependable.” For many fans, those traits align perfectly with the ideals of the United States—the very principles Captain America has always been meant to embody. However, Mackie’s remarks suggest a stark disconnect from that interpretation.
Of course, this isn’t the first time Mackie has cast doubt on Captain America’s connection to America. Ahead of the release of Disney+’s The Falcon and The Winter Soldier, Mackie expressed discomfort with the idea of taking on the mantle of Captain America.
Anthony Mackie behind the scenes of Marvel Studios’ CAPTAIN AMERICA: BRAVE NEW WORLD. Photo by Eli Adé. © 2024 MARVEL
READ: Exclusive: Insider Claims Rachel Zegler Snow White Box Office Could Derail Rey Movie, Frozen 3
In an earlier interview, he stated, “The fear of representing a country who doesn’t represent you, you know, was something that’s not only unfathomable, but hard to overcome. My dad always used to say greatness is as far as you can see it… There are limitations that we place on ourselves because of our surroundings. And, you know, I did that to myself, and that’s definitely what Sam Wilson goes through.”
While Mackie’s personal experiences may inform his perspective, many fans believe these statements miss the broader point of Captain America as a symbol. From the character’s inception, Steve Rogers—Captain America’s original alter ego—has stood for the American dream, for the principles enshrined in the Constitution, and for the unyielding belief that America can and should strive to be better. For Mackie to suggest that Captain America doesn’t or shouldn’t represent America is viewed by many as a fundamental misunderstanding of the character’s core purpose.
Marvel has also been historically timid about promoting Captain America overseas. The original film in the franchise, Captain America: The First Avenger, was originally released in Russia, Ukraine, and South Korea as simply The First Avenger.
Mackie’s comments have sparked widespread outrage online, with fans now calling for a boycott of Captain America: Brave New World.
What an ass Anthony Mackie is. Boycott Captain America movie. https://t.co/cDGun7gccG
— SJack (@jackson_steve) January 28, 2025
This is a major blow to a film that was already facing significant challenges, including low presale numbers, waning fan interest, and box office projections well below the profit margin for a film with such a massive budget.
Adding fuel to the fire, recent reports suggest that Brave New World has undergone four costly rounds of reshoots following disastrous test screenings. Industry insiders estimate the film’s true production cost to be between $350 million and $375 million, far higher than the $180 million figure recently floated by Deadline.
(L-R): Director Julius Onah, Xosha Roquemore, and Anthony Mackie behind the scenes of Marvel Studios’ CAPTAIN AMERICA: BRAVE NEW WORLD. Photo by Eli Adé. © 2024 MARVEL
With marketing expenses likely to double the overall cost, the movie will need to gross close to $1 billion globally just to break even—a nearly impossible task given its lackluster buzz and controversial lead actor.
The controversy surrounding Mackie’s comments and Brave New World’s troubled production are emblematic of a larger issue for Marvel Studios. The franchise has been facing diminishing returns at the box office, with films like The Eternals and The Marvels underperforming significantly. Both movies faced similar criticisms of focusing more on identity politics than strong storytelling, alienating long-time fans in the process.
Marvel has also faced backlash for mishandling its iconic characters. Chris Evans’ portrayal of Captain America resonated with audiences because it struck a perfect balance between patriotism and heroism, embodying the ideals of America while acknowledging the complexities of its flaws. Many fans feel that Marvel’s new approach, including Mackie’s controversial statements, undermines what made the character so beloved in the first place.
Chris Evans as Captain America in Captain America: Civil War (2016), Marvel Studios
With Captain America: Brave New World set to release on February 14, the studio now faces an uphill battle to win over audiences. If Mackie’s comments are any indication, the film may struggle to connect with fans who view Captain America as a timeless symbol of American ideals—something they feel Disney and Marvel no longer respect.
For a franchise built on the loyalty of its audience, this latest controversy could mark another step in Marvel’s rapid decline.
What do you think of Anthony Mackie and his comments about Captain America? Sound off in the comments below and let us know!
This is why he’s not fit to be Captain America.
You understand this because you have respect for America and don’t hate the country. It’d be like having someone who hates Japan representing Japan.
Guess why the woke don’t understand this.
This whole line was already doomed at the level of a falcon and a winter soldier, when they promised the idea that only a black hero could unite an American nation, because the blacks would not believe in a white hero. This not only show black Americans as racists, it also simply did not make sense in combination with narrative that white racists because they would not support the black hero in turn.
As bad as Walker was, they’ve done a fantastic job showing us hands down why he was a phenomenal choice compared to Wilson. They make it very easy to understand why the group at the beginning of F&WS never even considered Wilson.
Personally, I think they should have retired the shield altogether, but if they give it back to Walker, I wouldn’t object at this point. Walker wouldn’t be the worst choice.
It seems Anthony seemed to bet with someone that he would choose such an inappropriate and erroneous way to advance and so doomed film that this would eventually only finished it off.
Well to be fair, he’s certainly correct in that his version of Cap doesn’t represent America.
“Captain America shouldn’t represent America”–not the smartest way to promote a movie, and hopefully that brilliant comment will get Mackie out of the role even faster…
They never try putting the shoe on the other foot.
If an actor came here from England representing a Captain Britain film, and said the character doesn’t represent Britain I would think he’s dense and should have never been given the role.
What’s with these clowns inability to shove their feet in the mouths? Seriously? It’s quite amazing.
Do he and zieglly have the same agent?