Headline  ·  Marvel  ·  Movies  ·  News

Chris Evans Says Sam Wilson is Captain America in Avengers: Doomsday – ‘Steve is Just Steve’

Steve Rogers expressionless

Chris Evans as Steve Rogers in Avengers: Doomsday - Marvel Entertainment, YouTube

Chris Evans is returning for Avengers: Doomsday, but Marvel is drawing a firm line around his comeback. Steve Rogers is back, and the Captain America title still belongs to Anthony Mackie’s Sam Wilson.

“Steve is just Steve. Steve is not Captain America in this movie. That’s [Anthony] Mackie,” Evans told Empire, as reported by SuperHeroHype.

Evans was asked why Marvel has referred to his returning character as Steve Rogers. His answer reinforces the studio’s position, though it is unlikely to satisfy fans who still associate Captain America with the man who helped make the Avengers a box office phenomenon.

Steve Rogers Captain America running

Steve Rogers as Captain America – Disney+

READ: Variety Promotes Hunter Schafer as Robert Pattinson’s First Bond Girl

Marvel has already turned that disagreement into a joke.

Even Calling Steve “Cap” Requires a Correction

In a teaser that debuted during Game 1 of the World Series, Scott Lang (Paul Rudd) turns to Steve and calls him “Cap” out of habit. With Sam standing there, Scott quickly corrects himself and calls Sam “Cap” instead.

The joke depends on an association Marvel spent years building. Scott knows Steve as Captain America. So does the audience. Yet the scene treats that familiar nickname as something Scott needs to take back.

For viewers already frustrated with Marvel’s handling of the succession, the exchange gives them another reminder that Evans’ return comes with conditions. The studio is bringing back Steve while making a point of reserving his superhero identity for someone else.

Sam Wilson glares at Scott Lang

Sam Wilson and Scott Lang in Avengers: Doomsday – Marvel Entertainment, YouTube

READ: Disney Earnings: $10.1 Billion Parks Quarter, Tropical Americas Back to 2027 and an AI Trip Planner

The teaser puts the awkwardness on Scott, leaving the movie to establish how Steve and Sam actually feel about the situation. But Marvel’s decision to feature the correction in its advertising makes the title itself part of the sales pitch.

Chris Evans Was Reluctant to Return After Endgame

Evans also told Empire that Marvel executives Kevin Feige and Louis D’Esposito floated ideas for Steve to become Nomad while they were filming Avengers: Endgame. He felt those pitches didn’t fit where Steve’s story had landed and wanted a compelling reason to revisit the character.

That echoed what Evans told Entertainment Weekly in July. He recalled hearing at least a dozen pitches over eight years before agreeing to return for Doomsday.

Endgame gave Steve a life with Peggy Carter and ended with an older Steve handing his shield to Sam. Sam took up the mantle in The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, then headlined Captain America: Brave New World.

Marvel has spent years establishing that succession. Selling audiences on it has proved more difficult.

Marvel Wants Steve’s Appeal While Keeping Sam as Cap

Brave New World was still shy of $200 million domestically after eight weeks in theaters, as That Park Place reported. It finished with $200.5 million domestically and $415.1 million worldwide.

Sam Wilson as Captain America

Anthony Mackie as Sam Wilson/Captain America in Marvel Studios‘ CAPTAIN AMERICA: BRAVE NEW WORLD. Photo by Eli Adé. © 2024 MARVEL.

READ: New Magic Kingdom Construction Filing Points to Villains Land

That worldwide total exceeded the $370.6 million earned by Evans’ debut in The First Avenger. However, according to Box Office Mojo’s list of franchise totals, not adjusted for inflation, it fell far below The Winter Soldier at $714.4 million and Civil War at $1.15 billion. Civil War benefited from a large Avengers ensemble, but even The Winter Soldier earned nearly $300 million more than Sam’s first solo outing. 

Those numbers give Marvel little reason to assume audiences have embraced its preferred direction. Bringing Evans back offers an obvious way to revive interest, but insisting that “Steve is just Steve” risks undercutting the very appeal the studio is counting on.

For fans who want Evans back as Captain America, Marvel is selling a reunion with an asterisk. They recognize the hero on screen, while the studio keeps reminding them that his title belongs to Sam.

When Avengers: Doomsday opens December 18, Marvel will have to deliver more than an awkward correction and a familiar face. It has reopened Steve’s story to help sell another Avengers movie. Fans have every reason to expect a return worthy of Captain America.

How do you feel about Chris Evans saying that “Steve is just Steve” in Avengers: Doomsday? Sound off and let us know!

UP NEXT: McDonalds Launches Home Alone Themed Adult Happy Meal This Christmas

Trevor Denning’s work has appeared in The Banner, Upstream Reviews, and The Daily Caller, while his fiction is included in several anthologies from independent presses. A graduate of Cornerstone University in Grand Rapids, Mich., he currently resides in the palm of Michigan’s mitten. Most days you’ll find him at home, working out in his basement gym, cooking, and doting on his cats. You can follow him on X, Criticless, and YouTube at @BookstoreThor