On Wednesday, September 17, 2025, Cracker Barrel released its fourth-quarter earnings, reporting a 2.9% revenue decline compared to the same quarter last year and an 8% drop in guest traffic since the attempted rollout of a new streamlined logo in August.
The redesign removed the iconic “Uncle Herschel” figure, sparking immediate backlash. Just five days later, the company reversed course, announcing that the rebrand would not move forward.
A photo of Cracker Barrel CEO Julie Felss Masino – Photo Credit: Cracker Barrel
CEO Julie Masino acknowledged her misstep, admitting she had underestimated how deeply fans valued the traditional imagery.
“We want longtime fans and new guests to experience the full story of the people, places, and food that make Cracker Barrel so special,” she said. “That’s why our team pivoted quickly to switch back to our old-timer logo and has already begun executing new marketing, advertising, and social media initiatives leaning into Uncle Herschel and the nostalgia around the brand.”
The iconic rocking chairs outside Cracker Barrel – YouTube, TODAY
She added, “We thank our guests for sharing their voices and love for the brand and telling us when we’ve misstepped.”
Despite the reversal, Cracker Barrel stock slid about 9% in after-hours trading following the report.
Americana from the Heartland
Headquartered in Lebanon, Tennessee, Cracker Barrel has long represented the heartland of America—simpler times, family values, and front-porch conversations in rocking chairs.
Food at Cracker Barrel – YouTube, TODAY
READ: Former Disney CEO Michael Eisner Slams Leadership Over Jimmy Kimmel Suspension
The chain’s southern comfort food, paired with its “old country store” filled with retro candies, soda pop, and nostalgic gifts, offers both travelers and regulars a sense of home. For many, the logo itself embodies that warm welcome.
Critics argue that Masino either failed to recognize this or disregarded it entirely.
Julie Masino’s Taco Bell History
This isn’t the first time Masino has faced criticism for misreading a brand’s core identity.
Before joining Cracker Barrel, she served as President of Taco Bell North America (2018–2019) and later Taco Bell International (2020–2023). During her tenure, several fan-favorite items—including the quesarito, cheesy fiesta potatoes, the spicy potato soft taco, and, most famously, Mexican Pizza—were removed from the menu, drawing customer outrage.
Cracker Barrel CEO Julie Felss Masino – YouTube, TODAY
With a background at Starbucks, a brand with a distinctly different audience, Masino’s track record suggests repeated difficulty in aligning with the customer bases of heritage-driven brands like Taco Bell and now Cracker Barrel.
Calls for Resignation
Dissatisfaction with Masino’s leadership has fueled public calls for her resignation. Sardar Biglari, head of Steak ’n Shake and a major Cracker Barrel investor, has been vocal in demanding her removal.
Sardar Biglari wrote this cautionary prediction to Cracker Barrel shareholders on October 8, 2024:
“A Flawed Board Is Responsible for a Flawed Strategy
“The plan the Board has adopted involves remodeling the units with new booths and banquettes, which have not been part of…
— Steak ‘n Shake (@SteaknShake) September 10, 2025
READ: Disney Files Patent for AI‑Enhanced Projection Faces in Animatronic Characters
On September 9th, Steak ’n Shake’s official X account posted a blunt message quoting Biglari: “A Flawed Board Is Responsible for a Flawed Strategy.” The post ended with: “Fire the CEO!” Cracker Barrel co-founder Tommy Lowe also criticized the rebrand, calling Masino’s efforts “pitiful” and warning that abandoning the chain’s traditional roots risked long-term damage.
The stock drop after Cracker Barrel rebranded its iconic logo – YouTube, TODAY
While Lowe stopped short of directly demanding her firing, Biglari doubled down—going so far as to sponsor a Nashville billboard emblazoned with “Fire The CEO,” mocking the failed rebrand.
What’s Next for Cracker Barrel?
After spending an estimated $700 million on the aborted rebranding push, Masino now faces the daunting task of rebuilding trust with both customers and investors.
On the earnings call, she admitted, “We underestimated the emotional connection customers have with our traditional branding.” But still, she signaled an ongoing desire for modernization: “We are not leading in any area. We will change that.”
Cracker Barrel CEO Julie Felss Masino being interviewed – YouTube, TODAY
Her revised strategy pauses costly remodels but keeps certain modernization efforts alive. Supporters hope this balance will steady the company, but critics warn that any further departure from the chain’s nostalgic roots could deepen the disconnect with its loyal base—while still failing to deliver the turnaround Wall Street demands.
Do you believe the Cracker Barrel CEO? Sound off in the comments and let us know!
UP NEXT: Gino, Western Lowland Gorilla Patriarch, Dies at Disney’s Animal Kingdom at Age 44
