Few studios have experienced a more tumultuous journey in recent years than Monolith Productions. In October 2017, they released the second game in their Middle-earth series. This was a major critical and commercial success that sold over 10 million copies—a feat comparable to a blockbuster sweeping the box office.
One might have expected them to continue capitalizing on The Lord of the Rings franchise, but Monolith had other aspirations.
The Nemesis System in Middle Earth: Shadow of Mordor – YouTube, IGN
Instead, they embarked on an original IP codenamed Legacy, designed to elevate their innovative (and patented by WB Games) Nemesis System with new narrative depth. It held promise—until Warner Bros. terminated it in April 2021, setting off a chain of upheaval.
The cancellation proved devastating. Monolith’s entire leadership team, including studio head Kevin Stephens, resigned, and over 50 developers departed shortly after. Yet from this exodus emerged an unexpected development: many of those talents joined forces with Electronic Arts, establishing Cliffhanger Games in 2023. Their current project, a single-player Black Panther game, may yet carry echoes of Monolith’s procedural storytelling legacy.
A promotional image for the Wonder Woman video game – Monolith Productions
Back at Monolith, however, the focus shifted to recovery. By mid-2021, they began work on Wonder Woman, unveiling a teaser at The Game Awards that December. The challenge was immense: they were tasked with building a new game while simultaneously reconstructing their team—a feat akin to forging a masterpiece with fractured tools.
Progress faltered. A debate arose over whether to adopt Unreal Engine or retain their in-house technology, a system honed since F.E.A.R.’s era. They chose the latter, only to encounter persistent difficulties—largely because the engineers best equipped to navigate it had already left.
By late 2023, Wonder Woman faced a significant setback. Reports indicate a $100 million reboot, marked by a new director and a shift from an open-world, Nemesis-driven design to a more linear action-adventure format reminiscent of PlayStation originals like GOW.
A screenshot from Kratos (2018), Santa Monica Studios
READ: Dragon Age: The Veilguard Will Be Given Away for Free on PlayStation Just Four Months After Release
Updates grew scarce, hinting at deeper troubles.
On February 25, 2025, Warner Bros. Games delivered the final blow, announcing the closure of Monolith Productions alongside Player First Games and WB Games San Diego. Wonder Woman was abandoned, and 130 Seattle-based employees lost their positions.
Developers reportedly learned of the decision that Tuesday, mere hours before the public did, concluding a 31-year legacy with startling abruptness. Warner Bros. justified the move as a strategic pivot toward established franchises like Harry Potter and Mortal Kombat—a pattern of prioritizing safety over innovation also evident in the struggles of Rocksteady’s infamous Justice League disaster, which faltered as a live-service title in 2024 and lost the company $200 million.
This reflects a broader industry trend, with over 25,000 gaming jobs lost since 2023 as publishers increasingly favor proven IPs over untested ventures.
Raiden and Cyrax in Mortal Kombat (2011), NetherRealm Studios
What does this reveal?
Monolith’s bold pursuit of Legacy clashed with Warner Bros.’ more conservative vision, triggering a downward spiral. Wonder Woman became an attempt to salvage a sinking operation, but it couldn’t withstand the internal disarray.
Still, a glimmer of hope persists with Cliffhanger Games, where former Monolith developers might revive the spirit of their past innovations—perhaps even circumventing Warner Bros.’ Nemesis System patent. That possibility offers a faint silver lining.
Monolith’s story weaves together daring creativity and corporate missteps. Their portfolio—F.E.A.R., Shadow of Mordor, and more—secured their place in gaming history, yet Warner Bros.’ mismanagement sealed their fate.
A screenshot from Wonder Woman (TBA), Monolith Productions
The closure of Monolith Productions underscores a cautionary tale about stifling ambition in favor of safer bets. As we bid farewell to Monolith, attention turns to Cliffhanger Games, where the next chapter of this narrative may unfold.
How do you feel about WB Games shuttering Monolith Productions? Sound off in the comments and let us know!
Happy that this feminist cringe will never see the light of day.
Eventually someone will leak it and Batgirl when we have a Woke Museum to show later generations what never to repeat.
It’s simple what happened…dudes with passion for coding and game mechanics were replaced with people only looking to use the IP to push their worldview. If you’ll notice most AAA developers talk more about the story and “emotional journey” the game will take you through and rarely what the game offers as far mechanics are even basic technology. They always get all wrapped up in everything but the gameplay..hence why weak developers love “live service” games because theres usually templates they can just slap their half ass crap over. They had to build WW from the ground up, hence….
If you want an emotional journey, write a book, or a song, or anything else. So tired of “this should have been X”
It almost impossible to sell a “mechanic” to none gamers even to gamers, description of you do this and this happens is a tough pitch but an open world were you can climb this or swim in that. Then the abilities of the Devs come into effect do you get Ark/no man’s sky or monster hunter/eve
They always demand female versions of male characters like Space Marines. Does anyone believe that they would have allowed male characters as Amazons?
I’m not talking about trans because they believe trans women are women. I mean full on allowing anyone of any gender the way they demand of men.
No that was the point the women drove the men out of Themiskya as a lesbian commune.
Obvious double standards
[…] The closure of Monolith in February 2025 struck like a sudden cosmic silence to many because it wasn’t just a layoff or pivot; it was a dissolution of a 30-year vector of design thinking inside a larger corporate machine. Warner Bros. cut the studio amid restructuring and canceled its then-unreleased Wonder Woman project, ending a lineage that had helped define how atmospheric tension, humorous tone, and dynamic systems could cohere in first-person spaces. (That Park Place) […]